Back to the homepage

Book Review by Author and OL ('39): Jack Dixon

Posted: 1st April 2011

 

2010 is the 40th anniversary of the death of Air Chief Marshal Sir Hugh Dowding (later Lord Dowding) who master-minded the RAF’s victory in the battle of Britain. He oversaw the creation of Fighter Command during the late 1930s and thus played a unique role in the defence of these islands during the supreme emergency of 1940.  His investment in radar provided the RAF with an early warning system which time and again gave aircrews that precious breathing space to scramble the fighters thus avoiding annihilation on the ground. Britain’s late commitment to all-out rearmament, after the German entry into Prague in March 1939 had finally dispelled any lingering belief that Hitler would keep the Munich Agreement, meant that Fighter Command, which had been developing steadily since 1936, was the only section of Britain’s armed forces ready for war when it came in September.  In 1940, following the fall of France, Britain faced Germany alone in a battle which arguably would decide the fate of western civilisation. Dowding’s role in this pivotal conflict was a crucial one and he was credited with winning the Battle of Britain and awarded the Knight Grand Cross.  However his removal from office without promotion in November 1940 has remained an issue which raises many questions.

 

Jack Dixon’s excellent and carefully researched book provides many of the answers.  He reveals a conspiracy by fellow officers, which was to a large extent the result of a long standing dispute within the RAF about the so-called Trenchard Doctrine.  This involved an obsession with the importance of bombers.  Many in the RAF believed that the bomber would be a decisive weapon in a future conflict, but Dowding urged research and development of the fighter as he believed that the defence of Britain would be the principal necessity.  The subsequent production of the Hawker Hurricane and the Supermarine Spitfire alongside the development of radar, which became operational from 1937, was fully vindicated by the events of 1940, and made clear the flaws of the Trenchard Doctrine.  Jealousies and clashes of personalities abounded as Dowding had to fight against entrenched views and the ambitions of other officers to develop Fighter Command in the way that wanted.  All of this ensured that Dowding was not without enemies and played a large part in his early removal.  Sholto-Douglas and Leigh-Mallory criticised Dowding during the Battle of Britain for not being aggressive enough.  Dowding resisted their urges to send fighters further afield in order to meet German aircraft before they reached Britain, believing that this would lead to greater losses of trained pilots, a precious commodity.  Dixon examines the personalities, competence and motives of Sholto-Douglas and Leigh-Mallory along with Harris (later the famed head of Bomber Command), revealing weaknesses and human failings in all.  Even Churchill comes in for criticism as he appears to have been taken in by Dowding’s detractors and certainly acquiesced in Dowding’s move away from Fighter Command in November 1940.  This is a fascinating and well written book, assessing the achievements and treatment of one of the greatest Britons of the 20th century.

 

Born in Broadstairs, Jack (J.E.G) Dixon was sent to St. Edward’s, a local prep school.  However this closed in 1935 and he transferred to St. Lawrence College, where he was a day boy.  In his biographical sketch on the Amazon website, he describes the school thus: “This was a staunchly Low Church C of E school whose headmasters were ordained ministers. In 1935 the head was one Brackenbury, whose nickname was Creeping Jesus. It was the school's Christian duty to indulge in the caning of boys by both masters and prefects for trivial offences, such as exploring the foundations of a new building or shooting stones at another boy's pigeons. It is a better school today, although perhaps getting too democratic.” He remained at the College until 1939, leaving just before his 16th birthday.  In the summer of 1940 he worked as a labourer building invasion obstacles and thus had a good view of the Battle of Britain.  He trained as a pilot between 1943 and 1945, some of it in South Africa.  He remained in the RAF until 1948 and in 1949 he went up to Merton College, Oxford, where he took a degree in Modern Languages.  He also flew with the University Air Squadron.  Emigration to Canada in 1952 was followed by 5 years service in the Royal Canadian Air Force.  In 1959 he became a lecturer in French at the University of Winnipeg, where he remained until retiring to Vancouver Island in 1990 with his wife Rika.  He lists literature, cricket, fishing and aviation as among his interests and has written other published works including Concordance des Ouevres de François Rabelais (1992) and Aircrew Memories (1999).

 

Browse other upcoming events

Sign in to members area

Forgotten password?

Register as a member

You can become a member of this site and keep in touch with other Old Lawrentians. Please contact the Secretary, Kerry Brown.

Announcements

OL Dinner

A really splendid and historic venue has been selected for this year's OL Dinner. Drapers' Hall originally belonged to Thomas Cromwell before being seized by Henry VIII. The venue and the Drapers' history is very interesting. Why not take a look at http://www.thedrapers.co.uk Tickets are limited and going fast so please do book soon. Contact Kerry and Kelly in the OL office for more information. PLEASE BOOK AND PAY FOR YOUR TICKETS HERE ONLINE... <div id="bbox-root"></div> <script type="text/javascript"> window.bboxInit = function () { bbox.showForm('9581dd08-29b1-402c-87a6-6c433fefd5c7'); }; (function () { var e = document.createElement('script'); e.async = true; e.src = 'https://bbox.blackbaudhosting.com/webforms/bbox-min.js'; document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(e); } ()); </script>

More info »

4th SLC Kentish Fest

This is the 4th year we have held this fun, fundraising event and this year we are going even bigger and better and have dodgem cars! Always a sell out with 500 tickets available we urge you to book your places soon and ensure a great fun start to the summer holiday! Tickets are just £6 and include a pint poly SLC souvenir glass and 2 drinks tokens! Children do not need to purchase a £6 ticket & glass but can simply pay as they go for suitable refreshments. BOOK NOW, HERE ONLINE BY CLICKING READ MORE...

More info »

St Lawrence College event charity gala ball dinner saturday 26 May 2018

We are delighted to invite you to our Charity Gala Ball which is to be held in the Taylor Hall on Saturday 26th May 2018, with a drinks reception and an exclusive sneak preview in the new Science, Art and Technology building. This will be followed by a four course meal plus coffee and mints. Supporting the sports at St Lawrence College there will be an auction and raffle with lots and prizes including VIP packages for Formula 1, Lords cricket, International rugby and hockey sports memorabilia, a diamond necklace, plus entertainments, live music & dancing with Liberty Park. Tickets are £65.00 per person and for tables of 10 booked: £600.00 TO BOOK AND PAY ONLINE NOW CLICK READ MORE...

More info »

Old Lawrentian Contact Preferences

Inline with GDPR regulations (May 2018) we wish to ensure that we keep in contact with you by your preferred methods. By completing this 3 minute online form the OL Society and St Lawrence College can be sure to stay in touch with you in the ways that suit you. This information will only be used to update your Old Lawrentian profile and our communication system. Thank you for your assistance. <script>(function(t,e,s,n){var o,a,c;t.SMCX=t.SMCX||[],e.getElementById(n)||(o=e.getElementsByTagName(s),a=o[o.length-1],c=e.createElement(s),c.type="text/javascript",c.async=!0,c.id=n,c.src=["https:"===location.protocol?"https://":"http://","widget.surveymonkey.com/collect/website/js/tRaiETqnLgj758hTBazgd2ZLARR5BK6GAkEA2PyCwmclLDMFTB9zwvvo7lan5WZQ.js"].join(""),a.parentNode.insertBefore(c,a))})(window,document,"script","smcx-sdk");</script><a style="font: 12px Helvetica, sans-serif; color: #999; text-decoration: none;" href=https://www.surveymonkey.com> Create your own user feedback survey </a>

More info »

Chris Throndsen

6/3/1935 - 2/4/2018 It is with great sadness that we have to inform you of the passing of Old Lawrentian, Christopher Throndsen(Thronnie, aged 83. Pupil, Master, Head of House (Tower and Newlands), Past President and VP of the OL Society, member of the OL Golf Society and friend to many. A true Gentleman. There will be a private family funeral service held, then in May, a memorial service will be held at the College where everyone who knew Chris will be most welcome. We will notify everyone as soon as arrangements are confirmed. Our thoughts are with Francoise, Olaf and Isobel and their families at this sad time.

More info »

Service of Thanksgiving for Alexander Underhill

We were honoured to host a Service of thanksgiving for the life of Alex Underhill who had sadly passed away in 2017 on a hiking trip in Dubai.

More info »

© 2018 Old Lawrentian Society • Powered by Alumnusphere from CBJ Digital Ltd.

Find the Old Lawrentian Society on Faceboo Old Lawrentian Society LinkedIn profile